QualityTrails: Data Quality Provenance as a Basis for Sensemaking
نویسندگان
چکیده
Visual Analytics prototypes increasingly support human sensemaking through providing Provenance information. For data analysts the challenge of knowledge generation starts with assessing the quality of a data set, but Provenance is not yet utilized to aid this task. This position paper aims at characterizing the complexity of Visual Analytics methods introducing Provenance in Data Quality by highlighting the challenges of (1) generating Provenance from Data Quality Control and (2) sensemaking based on Data Quality Provenance.
منابع مشابه
Artifact Usefulness and Usage in Sensemaking Handoffs Authors
The complexities of sensemaking suggest that collaboration should be difficult, requiring a rich ecology of collaboration support. This can be a problem for handoff sensemaking, where one person must continue where another has left off, sometimes with only material artifacts as the basis of the handoff. A detailed analysis of essential attributes of sensemaking tasks, and elements identified in...
متن کاملUncertainty Propagation and Trust Building in Visual Analytics
Visual analytics combines human and machine abilities to generate new knowledge from data. Within this process, uncertainty often plays an important role in hindering the sensemaking process and analysis tasks. On the machine side, uncertainty builds up from the data source level to the visual output. On the human side, these uncertainties often result in “lack of knowledge or trust” or “overtr...
متن کاملSensemaking and Provenance in Distributed Collaborative Node-Link Visualizations
Various experts often work together during the analysis of large and complex data sets in order to minimize the required time and to improve the quality of the analysis results. Keeping track of the reasoning involved during a collaborative process and using this information later to review and reflect upon it can be a challenging task. For instance, analysts should have the possibility to quic...
متن کاملTrust and Risk Relationship Analysis on a Workflow Basis: a Use Case
Trust and risk are often seen in proportion to each other; as such high trust may induce low risk and vise versa. However, recent research argues that trust and risk relationship is implicit rather than proportional. Considering that trust and risk are implicit, this paper proposes for the first time a novel approach to view trust and risk on a basis of a provenance data model (W3C PROV) applie...
متن کاملSensemaking in the Fog of War: An Experimental Study of HowCommand Teams Arrive at a Basis for Action
A commander and his staff have to use whatever information is available to arrive at an understanding of the situation that can serve as a basis for action, hence sensemaking has a central role in the C2 process. This paper reports the results of a first experimental study of the sensemaking process in a command team. The participants were 99 Army captains studying at the Swedish National Defen...
متن کامل